Marketing and communications teams often face the same question: Can we handle this internally or do we need external support? This guide outlines key criteria for you to consider to help you make informed decisions and sustainable results.
Expertise & know-how
The first and most obvious question is: Does my team have the necessary expertise and skills to do the job well? If not, you have two options: build expertise internally through training, or bring in an agency to close the gap.
Outside perspective (freedom and creativity)
When you’re caught up in the day-to-day,, it’s easy to lose sight of the bigger picture. An outside perspective can help. Agencies challenge the status quo, contribute new ideas and offer creative impulses that an established team might lack. So ask yourself: Could a fresh outside perspective be just what we need to move forward?
Neutrality in the case of internal disagreements
Some projects stall due to conflicting priorities or unclear responsibilities. An agency can step in as a neutral party, drive decisions forward and help resolve gridlocked processes. Especially in sensitive or conflict-prone projects, this can provide a decisive push. Agencies also bring in new methods, a bird’s eye perspective, sharper questions and a pace that initiates or accelerates internal change.
Learning potential of the team
A benefit that is often overlooked is: working with an agency can be a powerful learning experience for a team. Employees can observe how professionals structure tasks and approach complex problems and adopt these strategies for future challenges. The learning effect should be considered in the decision. Whether SEO, UX, crisis communication or community management – agencies offer specialist knowledge that could take months or years to build in house. They are also able to share best practices from other industries that often trigger aha moments!
Resources & capacity
You’ve got the skills but not the time? This is common. When day-to-day operations don’t leave room for additional projects or implementing new tools, an agency can step in and bridge the gap. The key question is: Does my team have the capacity to implement this properly?
Budget
Yes, agency support costs money, and your staff . are already on the payroll. Still, it’s worth taking a closer look: Could an agency free up your team to focus on what matters most and deliver better results, faster? Agencies often provide short-term support and help bridge bottlenecks, especially during product launches, crises or seasonal campaigns.
Reputation and credibility
In certain situations, such as stakeholder communication, political initiatives or sensitive reputation work it may be wise to involve a trusted agency. Their external viewpoint can lend additional weight to your arguments, especially when internal opinions gain weight through external validation.. This can strengthen your position with key decision-makers.
There is no one-size-fits-all answer when you’re asking “Agency or no agency?” but the right questions help lead to the right solution. Sometimes, simply taking the time to reflect is the first step toward a better outcome.
Are you currently facing this decision?
We’d be happy to support you as a sparring partner, a source of inspiration or an implementation team.
Get in touch, no strings attached.
